Advertisement

The NASCAR rule Formula 1 should use to avoid another Abu Dhabi debacle

NASCAR have long used a rule which Formula 1 could learn from

-

Formula 1 fans across the world are still debating the controversial ending to the 2021 Abu Dhabi GP, and the FIA have announced series of meetings will take place with the teams and drivers to discuss the final laps of the race, including the Safety Car procedure.

In a statement on January 13, the FIA spoke out for the first time since the announcement that they would launch an inquiry into the events that took place at the Yas Marina circuit, hinting at possible rule changes.

“The FIA President [Ben Sulayem] launched a consultation with all F1 teams on various issues, including this one,” said the FIA statement.

“On January 19, an item on the agenda of the Sporting Advisory Committee will be dedicated to the use of the Safety Car.”

Of course, the detailed analysis has been triggered by the circumstances which led to Max Verstappen‘s last lap, title-winning overtake on Lewis Hamilton.

Hamilton was leading the Grand Prix and had everything under control until Nicholas Latifi crashed with five laps to go.

The accident led to a Safety Car and it was not clear whether Latifi’s car would be cleared in time for a restart. Initially, the lapped cars were not going to be waved by, which is what happened at the 2020 Eifel GP. This is within the rules.

However, F1 race director Michael Masi made a very late call to only let five cars unlap themselves. These five cars were the drivers in between Hamilton and Verstappen.

The controversy here is the other lapped cars were not allowed to be waved by. Masi also failed to follow a regulation which states the Safety Car should not pit at the end of the same lap when a wave by takes place, so two clear rules were broken in Abu Dhabi.

Formula 1 race director Michael Masi

What’s the solution?

This whole sags is much bigger than simply Masi as race director. F1 must put in the right protocols to prevent another race ending in controversial circumstances due to the use of the Safety Car.

Throwing a red flag, if there’s an incident within the final five laps, seems to be one clear solution which is what happened at the 2021 Azerbaijan GP.

The only problem with this is the standing start restart. Yes, they can be exciting and dramatic but the likelihood of another crash is quite high because some drivers will feel they have nothing to lose, which could led to another accident.

This could lead to another stoppage, or a Safety Car where the race would then end with no more green flag running which no racing fan wants to see. To prevent this, perhaps F1 should look to NASCAR.

NASCAR’s Green-White-Checker (G-W-C) rule offers the chance of a race ending under green flag conditions. The way the regulation works is if the race is under caution (behind a Safety Car) with two laps to go, the number of laps left is frozen, so there isn’t an anti-climatic ending.

If F1 implemented this rule, the teams would know there is guaranteed to be a two-lap sprint with a normal safety car restart which would include allowing all lapped cars to be waved by.

This would give the teams a fair chance to think about their strategies and consider what is the optimal way to finish the race and beat their rival.

There is also less chance of a major crash on a safety car restart compared to a standing start restart, so it’s likely the final two laps can be run under green flag conditions.

One problem might be fuel. Depending on the speed of the Safety Car, the drivers can save up to half a lap of fuel when running behind the Safety Car, compared to green flag conditions.

If the Safety Car is expected to be quite long and there is a possibility most drivers will run out of fuel, the race director can simply red flag the race before sending everyone back out again for the G-W-C.

However, you will not be allowed to change tyres during a red flag, so any strategic games will have to be done when the Safety Car comes out.

This is an ideal and more importantly fair solution to end a race if there is an accident in the closing stages of a Grand Prix.

Formula One F1 – Abu Dhabi Grand Prix – Yas Marina Circuit, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates – December 12, 2021 Red Bull’s Max Verstappen crosses the line to win the race and the world championship Pool via REUTERS/Kamran Jebreili

How would a G-W-C work at 2021 Abu Dhabi GP?

If F1 had these rules in the 2021 season-finale, Mercedes almost certainly would have pitted Hamilton. One reason they didn’t is because it wasn’t clear if the race was going to end behind the Safety Car. If Masi followed the regulations, this would have been the case and Mercedes would have made the right choice.

Masi would have been under huge pressure to have a green flag finish, hence why he told Toto Wolff, “We went motor racing” in the aftermath of the Grand Prix.

A G-W-C rule means the race director isn’t under pressure to rush the situation in order to get a race to the chequered flag.

Under this scenario, Red Bull would likely pit Verstappen because holding off Hamilton on an old set of hard tyres, with two laps to go, would be a huge task.

It’s not a certainty though they would have gone for the track position route, which is the great thing about a G-W-C because the strategic element remains, whereas a red flag causes everyone to put a new set of tyres on their car for the standing start restart.

We’ll find out if F1 decide to make any significant changes to the Safety Car regulations, especially when there’s an incident during the latter stages of a Grand Prix, in February when their findings are presented to the F1 Commission. F1 cannot afford a repeat of the mess caused by Masi at the 2021 Abu Dhabi GP.

16 COMMENTS

  1. I am tired of everyone saying that Hamilton would have won. The fact is that we will never know this. Simply put in the remaining time of the race under safety car he could have had several things go wrong however these are hardly or were likely to occur but still they could have done so, These being a puncture, engine failure, gearbox failure etc. any of which could have prevented him from finishing. That is possibly one reason why the result would never be reversed and overturned as you never know the other outcome. Sure the race re-started but then the cars were at racing speed and hot having to stay at a certain speed. So yes I support a revision of the rules if that means a fair result is obtained. Instead of all this stop start stuff and GWC, add up all the laps of a race wasted on safety car being deployed and allow a refuel of each car with enough fuel for these recovered laps. Then start the cars from the grid with a spacing equal to the time they finished in front at the end of the actual race so as to preserve the lead. So if it was 10 laps of the safety car and the race leader finished 12 seconds in front of the second car then the ‘extra-time added on’ race would have the leader start and then 12 seconds later the second driver start and so-on

    • What do you mean? If Masi didn’t pull the SC in earlier than the rules say by using his veto to do whatever he wants, the race would have finished under safety car and Hamilton would have won. PERIOD. As there wouldnt have been any way for Verstappen to pass as Hamilton did stay out…

    • You seem not to have grasped the reality of this rule change, only concentrating on what could have happened to Hamilton, in reality anything could of happened to any driver, evenMax, the one major fact you’ve avoided is the race order/positions would have been maintained and whatever happened to any driver would in the eyes of the world, been a fairer outcome than what occurred, which purely by the FIA holding an investigation into this debacle, is an admission by them that they realise they did wrong and need to clear it up or face losing huge amounts of revenue from both sponsors and the viewing public not wanting to be involved with an amateur outfit that has unprofessional rules that appear to manipulate race outcomes.

  2. Won’t work. F1 cars are fueled for the race distance plus enough for the FIA sample after the race. Not enough fuel for green-white-checker.

    • Right so, if you use your brain just a little bit, they would have also have to increase the fuel capacity by around 3.5%.

  3. The NASCAR G-W-C process is an improvement on the current F1 process for dealing with a safety car incident close to the end; however it is still unfair because any lead built up over the race is wiped out and lapped cars, that a leader has had to pass, get removed from cars following behind. I like the idea of discounting the laps driven under a safety car; however, as pointed out this risks running out of fuel, or ending the race with insufficient fuel to meet the race minimum. My recommendation is explained here:
    https://jeremydainesblog.substack.com/p/formula-1-abu-dhabi-race-controversy
    this maintains each cars’ position (time gap) so the restart occurs with exactly the same position and nominal time gaps. This would ensure the 1-lap shoot-out seen in Abu Dhabi could not happen again.

  4. Thats an option.

    However the main reason i feel hamilton never pitted in abu dhabi for new tyres was track position. Verstappen showed lap one you cannot overtake him fairly – he will always push you off track.

    Mercedes could never ever concede track position to dirty verstappen and that will not change until he is forced to by other drivers standing up to him or the FIA grows a pair.

  5. What if 3 safety car laps counted as 1 racing lap
    This corrects for fuel usage
    but retains as many racing laps as possible

  6. a much simpler way would close the pit entrance for the first lap of a safety car this then gives the lead car that some times as passed the pit entrance time to make a decision.

  7. What do you mean? If Masi didn’t pull the SC in earlier than the rules say by using his veto to do whatever he wants, the race would have finished under safety car and Hamilton would have won. PERIOD. As there wouldnt have been any way for Verstappen to pass as Hamilton did stay out…

  8. Just make a rule that states that when safety car is deployed, lead car is the first car that is allowed to pit on the first safety car lap without incurring a penalty.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Must Read

George Russell at the 2022 Belgian Grand Prix

Russell: Mercedes definitely had a car capable of winning

0
Despite finishing last of the 14 drivers who crossed the line at the 2022 Singapore Grand Prix, George Russell insists Mercedes had a car...
- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -