Caution causes more questions for Formula E 2023

Formula E 2023 didn't get off to a fiery, exciting start with the first race of the new Gen3 era, but we cannot judge it on just one event


It wasn’t exactly your typical exciting Formula E race on Saturday as Jake Dennis dominated the season-opening Mexico City E-Prix. Huge credit to him and Andretti first of all.

Thinking bigger picture, Gen3 failed to seriously grab the headlines or the attention of people who might be more new to Formula E, but it wasn’t all doom and gloom either.

This season will have a close championship and many title contenders which we shouldn’t take for granted. However, it already feels like Formula E may have missed an opportunity to make a name for itself if Mexico is anything to go by.

Worse racing with Gen3?

The three safety car periods exacerbated how the E-Prix felt, but the green flag period we had in the second half of the race didn’t make you go wow.

Di Grassi discussed the possibility of the drivers not being able to follow as closely with the new car due to the faster speeds. Instead, it seems that attack mode is less effective this season.

To create overtaking, you need a big difference in speed and the lap time comparison between the normal 300kW race mode and 350kW when in attack mode wasn’t enough.

Formula E‘s new attack mode regulations mean the drivers use four minutes of attack mode during the race. They can do this in three ways: 2+2, 3+1 or 1+3 minutes.

In previous seasons, it was mostly eight minutes so the time to make an undercut or overcut was less and many drivers copied each other.

There was visibly less lift and coast too, with the hard Hankook tyre making it difficult to carry more speed through the corners than the car in front.

Don’t be surprised if there is a mid-season regulation change to the attack mode. Any tyre changes will have to wait until Season 10 at the earliest.

Dennis in a menacing mood

It was a devastatingly good drive from Dennis, reminiscent of his performance from London Race 1 in 2022 when he won on home soil.

The drivers who understood the new car and tyres best were going to come out on top. Interestingly, all the Porsche powered cars, so Andretti and the factory Porsche team, looked very good in Mexico City.

Porsche had a 1-2 at the Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez in 2022, so perhaps there is something to do with the altitude or the conditions that favour the German manufacturer.

Jake Dennis, Avalanche Andretti Formula E , 1st position, fans celebration

Dennis made the most of it and capitalised on a mistake from Di Grassi, before cruising away.

“I’m ecstatic,” said Dennis. “We came into this weekend with the unknown of where we were going to be, but we came out with the win, a front-row start and the fastest lap of the race.

“We couldn’t have asked for a better first day in Gen3. A big shout out to the team and a big shout out to Porsche for giving us such an efficient powertrain.

“Now we focus on Saudi – it’s less than two weeks away. We’ve got a lot of work to do, but we can enjoy this one for now.”

Di Grassi’s defensive masterclass

With three percent less energy than the cars around him with a dozen laps to go, Di Grassi appeared to be in big trouble.

Pascal Wehrlein made quick work of the Mahindra driver by getting a simple move done into the new chicane down the back straight.

But, rookie Jake Hughes was perhaps found out in terms of racecraft as he struggled to get close enough on the key parts of the track to overtake Di Grassi.

Jake Dennis, Avalanche Andretti, 1st position, Pascal Wehrlein, Porsche, 2nd position, Lucas di Grassi, Mahindra, 3rd position. 2023 Mexico City E-Prix | Formula E

Hughes took some unusual lines and wasted his energy with half-hearted moves. That said, his speed in Mexico was impressive.

Andre Lotterer is a wily, clever driver like Di Grassi and made the most of Hughes‘ inexperience by getting past on the penultimate lap as the McLaren driver was confused by a yellow flag that had changed to a red and yellow slippery surface flag.

It was great racing but it still feels like more is to come from Gen3 compared to the action we had with Gen2. All those drivers we have just talked about though were superb.

What happened to Maserati?

DS Penske and Maserati were expected to be the teams to beat in the season-opener, but they were nowhere.

Maximilian Gunther, who was fastest in pre-season testing, Jean-Eric Vergne, Edoardo Mortara and Stoffel Vandoorne all qualified outside of the top 10, with only the latter finishing in the points.

It was a big surprise as neither driver had great pace or efficiency. Perhaps every other team moved forward from Valencia and the Maserati-powered cars stood still.

The margins are still very tight too, we are talking hundredths of a seconds, but it is surely no coincidence that some powertrains fared better than others in Mexico.

Due to the high rate of learning and development, the pecking order will likely change again in Saudi Arabia. If Maserati are off the pace in Diriyah at the end of January, then there will be strong doubts about their championship hopes.

New brake system introduced for Diriyah

And lastly back to the cars. The FIA are set to introduce a secondary braking system in an attempt to prevent high-speed crashes that have marred the build-up to Gen3.

During Friday practice in Mexico, Mitch Evans had an unseen off which allegedly was caused by the car’s systems shutting down, so he was unable to stop before hitting the barrier head on.

Another braking system will be added, potentially from Diriyah on January 27-28, which is one benefit of Formula E having standardised parts including the brakes. It will come as much relief to the drivers.

Reliability wasn’t as big of an issue as some teams feared which is only good news as parts failing, which are not the fault of the engineers or mechanics, is incredibly frustrating and a championship shouldn’t be decided on luck.

Download the 2023 Formula E calendar so you don’t miss any of the action.

It still didn’t feel like Gen3 was as entertaining as it could have been. You get once chance to get a new set of regulations right and to bring a new audience with a car and racing that is exciting.

Maybe we just need time to get used to this new era and the cautious from the drivers and teams played a part too. After all, it’s been one race that lasted 107km, the longest distance of any Formula E race ever.

Onwards and upwards from here, don’t give up on Formula E 2023 yet. And certainly don’t make any conclusions.

Nigel Chiu
Nigel Chiu
Nigel Chiu is an NCTJ-qualified journalist who worked at Total-Motorsport for 18 months until May 2023. He has been following F1 since 2007 and hasn’t missed a Grand Prix weekend since. Nigel’s worked with several motorsport websites, plus Eurosport and subsequently went on to work with Sky Sports where he travels to multiple F1 races each season.
- Advertisment -


Jake Dennis of Andretti at the 2024 Misano E-Prix | Formula E

Dennis: Formula E brings something different, F1 is just a procession

Jake Dennis believes Formula E's peloton style of racing brings something different to motorsport in an era where Formula...
Pascal Wehrlein in action during the 2024 Misano E-Prix | Formula E

Wehrlein Secures Dramatic Misano E-Prix Win After Rowland Runs Out of Energy

In a stunning turn of events at the 2024 Misano E-Prix, Pascal Wehrlein seized a dramatic victory, capitalising on...
Pascal Wehrlein at the 2024 Misano E-Prix | Porsche Formula E Team

Results for Misano E-Prix 2024 Formula E Round 7

A dramatic end to Formula E Round 7 at the 2024 Misano E-Prix saw leader Oliver Rowland run out...
Oliver Rowland, Sebastien Buemi and Sam Bird battle at the Misano E-Prix | Formula E

Formula E LIVE: Misano E-Prix 2024 – Wehrlein wins on dramatic last lap

Welcome to this Total Motorsport Live Blog for Round 7 of the 2024 Formula E World Championship, where history is set...
William Byron and crew chief Rudy Fugle celebrate victory in Martinsville in 2024 | NASCAR

How often are NASCAR Cup Series podium sweeps?

It almost feels too good to be true. Hendrick Motorsports winning on the 40-year anniversary of their first ever...
Lewis Hamilton faces the media at the 2024 Japanese GP | Jiri Krenek / Mercedes F1 team

Lewis Hamilton discusses the challenge of transitioning to Ferrari

Lewis Hamilton has admitted that he's not sure how to navigate the transition from Mercedes to Ferrari as it...
Antonio Felix da Costa looks on ahead of the 2024 Misano E-Prix | Formula E

Antonio Felix da Costa stripped of Misano E-Prix victory

Antonio Felix Da Costa of Porsche has been disqualified from the inaugural Misano E-Prix, resulting in his loss of...
Mitch Evans during the 2024 Misano E-Prix | Jaguar Formula E Team / LAT Images

Mitch Evans brands Max Gunther driving ‘dirty’ and ‘ridiculous’

Mitch Evans has hit out at Maximilian Gunther's driving in the first 2024 Misano E-Prix after the pair battled...
Mitch Evans leads the field in the first 2024 Misano E-Prix | Formula E

Is Formula E ‘crazy’ peloton-style racing too dangerous?

If you turned on the TV and watched the first 2024 Misano E-Prix, you would have seen Formula E...
Antonio Felix da Costa celebrates victory after the first 2024 Misano E-Prix | Formula E

Da Costa triumphs for Porsche in chaotic Misano E-Prix

Antonio Felix Da Costa triumphed in an electrifying race for Round 6 of the Misano E-Prix, marking his first...
- Advertisment -