Were the FIA right to sack Masi as F1 race director?

The repercussions are starting to be felt after the FIA investigation into 2021 Formula 1 finale


Michael Masi‘s reign as Formula 1 race director has come to an end following his part in the controversial conclusion to the 2021 Formula 1 World Championship.

Masi‘s future was in jeopardy after the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix, and the FIA have announced he will be replaced by World Endurance Championship race director Eduardo Freitas and DTM race director Niels Wittich.

The FIA had very little choice but to remove Masi, because the trust between the teams and the New Zealander was certainly not strong.

Have the FIA made the right decision?

The 2021 Abu Dhabi GP will always be seen as one of the biggest controversies in any sport.

Masi‘s name is now widely associated with his call which led to Max Verstappen having the opportunity to overtake Lewis Hamilton to win the title.

Formula One – Abu Dhabi Grand Prix – Yas Marina Circuit, Abu Dhabi, 2021 Red Bull’s Max Verstappen crosses the line to win the race and the world championship Pool via REUTERS/Kamran Jebreili

F1 can’t afford to continue having its reputation tarnished by keeping Masi and further poor decisions from the former F1 race director would have come under the spotlight more than normal.

It wasn’t just Abu Dhabi where Masi made a big mistake. In 2020, Lance Stroll had a near-miss with a marshal when unlapping himself under the Safety Car.

Just two weeks later, Masi started the second period of qualifying at the Turkish GP whilst a tractor was still recovering the stricken Williams of Nicholas Latifi.

To 2021, inconsistencies with penalties, a very late Safety Car call which led to cars charging past Verstappen‘s wrecked Red Bull on the main straight, a farce in Belgium, plus the radio communication between the race director and the teams exposed Masi, showing he wasn’t quite ready to fill in the shoes of Charlie Whiting.

Have the FIA created a new problem?

Wittich and Freitas are excellent appointments, with plenty of experience and great reputations in their respective series.

Wittich and Freitas

Freitas in particular was universally loved for his calm, clear approach which set the tone for a clinical race direction in WEC.

However, it’s highly unusual to have two race directors for one championship. Yes, there are a record-breaking 23 events on the 2022 F1 calendar, but they Wittich and Freitas will need to ensure they are on exactly the same page.

It’s a small risk, but the experience of both men and the return of Herbie Blash, who served as F1’s deputy race director from 1995 to 2016, as a permanent senior advisor are very positive moves from the FIA.

A fresh start for F1

F1 in 2022 marks a new era with new cars and regulations, so it’s the perfect time to wipe the slate clean following a thrilling, but at times questionable, stewarding and race direction.

Mohammed ben Sulayem

FIA President Mohammed ben Sulayem has had a very challenging two months since taking over from Jean Todt and he’s already had to make some big calls.

A good referee, or in motorsport’s case a race director, should feature very little in the news and that was Masi‘s biggest problem during his three-year stint.

The job as F1 race director is tough, but there is a line when it comes to the impact and the number of mistakes. Arguably, Masi crossed that line before Abu Dhabi, and his decision astthe season-finale was the final nail in the coffin.

Along with new appointments, the banning of lobbying games to the race director from the teams, and the introduction of a Virtual Race Control Room, the FIA have pushed the sport into the right direction again and nobody can criticise that.

Nigel Chiu
Nigel Chiuhttps://total-motorsport.com/author/nigel-chiu/
Nigel Chiu is an NCTJ-qualified journalist who worked at Total-Motorsport for 18 months until May 2023. He has been following F1 since 2007 and hasn’t missed a Grand Prix weekend since. Nigel’s worked with several motorsport websites, plus Eurosport and subsequently went on to work with Sky Sports F1 where he travels to multiple F1 races each season.
- Advertisment -


Nick Cassidy in action at the 2024 London E-Prix | Formula E

Formula E 2024 LIVE: London E-Prix Finale – Cassidy on pole

Welcome to this Total-Motorsport.com Formula E LIVE BLOG for Round 16 from the 2024 London E-Prix! This Sunday, we bring you real-time updates,...
Oscar Piastri in action at the 2024 Hungarian GP | McLaren

Oscar Piastri Takes Debut F1 Victory at Hungarian GP Amid McLaren Drama

Oscar Piastri has clinched his first-ever Formula 1 victory at the 2024 Hungarian GP, after a dramatic race filled...
Oscar Piastri of McLaren leads Lando Norris and Max Verstappen into Turn 1 at the start during the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

F1 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix – Race Results

The 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix race weekend took us through the midpoint of the Formula 1 season, and Oscar Piastri took the chequered flag to...
Sergio Perez during practice ahead of the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

F1 LIVE: 2024 Hungarian GP – Piastri wins after Norris finally follows team orders

Welcome to this Total-Motorsport.com F1 Live Blog for the 2024 Hungarian GP! This Sunday, we bring you real-time updates,...
Lando Norris during practice at the 2024 Hungarian GP | McLaren F1 Team

Lando Norris confident McLaren will win after bagging 2024 Hungarian GP pole

Lando Norris is confident McLaren will win the 2024 Hungarian GP, owing to their impressive performance in race simulations...
George Russell in action at the 2024 Hungarian GP | Mercedes

Angry George Russell calls for Mercedes internal review after qualifying disaster

An angry George Russell called for a review within Mercedes after poor qualifying execution at the 2024 Hungarian Grand...
Oscar Piastri in the pit garage at the 2024 Austrian GP | McLaren F1 Team

Oscar Piastri hints at Lando Norris battle for 2024 Hungarian GP win

Oscar Piastri pointed to the long run down to Turn 1 at the Hungaroring as a potential way to...
Lewis Hamilton in action at the 2024 Hungarian GP | Mercedes

Lewis Hamilton targeting podium at 2024 Hungarian GP

Lewis Hamilton is aiming for a podium at the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix although he concedes McLaren and Red...

Max Verstappen slams Red Bull upgrade: Whole weekend not good enough

Max Verstappen ripped into Red Bull’s latest upgrade by declaring the whole weekend has been below his standards after...
Pascal Wehrlein of Porsche and Jaguar driver Mitch Evans during Round 15 at the London E-Prix | Formula E

Formula E title permutations and standings ahead of 2024 London E-Prix season finale

Things are hotting up in London as Nick Cassidy claimed pole position for the final race of the season...
- Advertisment -