F1 super licence rules must change, IndyCar deserves more respect

The super licence system has polarised the Formula 1 world with Colton Herta agreeing to join AlphaTauri for 2023, but there's one major hurdle for him to overcome


Formula 1‘s super licence was designed to prohibit the likes of Max Verstappen coming into the sport without enough single-seater experience, but it’s now stopping drivers who are more than talented enough to be part of the grid.

Young IndyCar star Colton Herta has been reported to have agreed a deal to join AlphaTauri for 2023, with Pierre Gasly joining Alpine to replace Fernando Alonso. However, there is one big hurdle to overcome which is preventing these moves from happening.

Herta doesn’t have enough super licence points to secure a place in F1. He is set to have 32 points, depending on where he finishes in this year’s IndyCar championship which finishes this Sunday, which is eight points short of the 40 required.

Red Bull say they are in talks with the FIA to allow Herta onto the grid anyway, but the main point here is, we shouldn’t even be discussing this. Something needs to change about the super licence regulations or the points that are awarded.

This is bigger than Colton Herta

Forget Herta for a moment, the key thing here is why IndyCar is completely undermined by the super licence points system.

How can it be that a fourth place finish in the IndyCar championship awards the same amount of points as DTM, which is not even a single-seater series. How can winning Formula Mazda equate to fourth place in IndyCar? The list of examples is endless.

IndyCar requires just as much skill as F1, it’s single-seater racing at high speeds, on great old-school circuits in a highly competitive field.

For a big more perspective, Romain Grosjean, Marcus Ericsson, Alexander Rossi and Takuma Sato technically wouldn’t be allowed to drive in F1 because they do not have enough super licence points.

All four of those drivers have raced in F1, Grosjean the most recent in 2020, so it’s ludicrous that they wouldn’t be able to return to the grid.

Quite frankly, finishing in the top five in any IndyCar championship over the last decade should be enough to drive in F1.

Will there be an exemption for Herta?

Alfa Romeo team principal Frederic Vasseur, HaasGuenther Steiner and MercedesToto Wolff all oppose an exemption for Herta.

“From my point of view, it has nothing to do with force majeure, because you have championships everywhere in the world that you were able to score points, if the FIA want to stop the process of the points, and the super licence it’s another story,” said Vasseur.

“But they can do it and it’s up to them to decide if they want to stop the system and we can survive without the system, but nothing to do for me with force majeure.”

Steiner added: “I think we have got rules and regulations which we need to respect. If we don’t respect our own rules and try to find ways around it I don’t think that’s correct.

“I mean, we could then apply that to other things as well and I’m not speaking in general about rules. It’s like, we made them ourselves, if we signed on to them, there is a governance and we need to respect it.”

Herta is McLaren‘s test and development driver, having tested the team’s 2021 machine earlier this year at Portimao.

Andreas Seidl was in the same press conference as Steiner and Vasseur, and stated he would be happy to see some flexibility for Herta.

“[I am] absolutely open for some flexibility there and handing a guy like Colton the super licence,” said Seidl.

“In the end, with what he has shown so far in his racing career, I have no doubt that he is absolutely able to compete in F1.”

Do super licences need to exist?

In an era where there are so many talented drivers, F1 is in a great place. There need to be more teams, which looks unlikely to happen but let’s save that for another day, and fans want to see the best grid possible.

Common sense needs to prevail here because if a driver like Herta isn’t allowed on the grid, something is wrong, very wrong.

As Vasseur alluded to, the original reason for the super licence is to make sure F1 doesn’t have lots of pay drivers who haven’t had good enough results in junior series.

That’s a fair point, but would that really happen now? Probably not. There wouldn’t be any more so-called pay drivers on the grid than there currently are.

Colton Herta wins the 2022 GMR Grand Prix at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway, Credit – Penske Entertainment: Joe Skibinski

Going back to IndyCar, the other reason the FIA may be reluctant to change the points system is because they want drivers to come through the Formula 4, Formula 3 and Formula 2 ranks.

For drivers, it would be much cheaper to go to America, race in Indy Lights and then IndyCar, rather than paying millions to race in F2 and F3.

If IndyCar was given the same points as F2 for instance, many young drivers would flock to the United States simply for cost reasons and the FIA wouldn’t want this.

For the sake of racing though, something must change. First, Herta must be given an exemption to race in F1 next year, especially when Liberty Media are pushing to truly crack the American market.

Then either IndyCar needs to be awarded more super licence points for championship finishing positions, or just get rid of the super licence altogether.

Nigel Chiu
Nigel Chiuhttps://total-motorsport.com/author/nigel-chiu/
Nigel Chiu is an NCTJ-qualified journalist who worked at Total-Motorsport for 18 months until May 2023. He has been following F1 since 2007 and hasn’t missed a Grand Prix weekend since. Nigel’s worked with several motorsport websites, plus Eurosport and subsequently went on to work with Sky Sports F1 where he travels to multiple F1 races each season.
- Advertisment -


Nick Cassidy in action at the 2024 London E-Prix | Formula E

Formula E 2024 LIVE: London E-Prix Finale – Cassidy on pole

Welcome to this Total-Motorsport.com Formula E LIVE BLOG for Round 16 from the 2024 London E-Prix! This Sunday, we bring you real-time updates,...
Oscar Piastri in action at the 2024 Hungarian GP | McLaren

Oscar Piastri Takes Debut F1 Victory at Hungarian GP Amid McLaren Drama

Oscar Piastri has clinched his first-ever Formula 1 victory at the 2024 Hungarian GP, after a dramatic race filled...
Oscar Piastri of McLaren leads Lando Norris and Max Verstappen into Turn 1 at the start during the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

F1 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix – Race Results

The 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix race weekend took us through the midpoint of the Formula 1 season, and Oscar Piastri took the chequered flag to...
Sergio Perez during practice ahead of the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

F1 LIVE: 2024 Hungarian GP – Piastri wins after Norris finally follows team orders

Welcome to this Total-Motorsport.com F1 Live Blog for the 2024 Hungarian GP! This Sunday, we bring you real-time updates,...
Lando Norris during practice at the 2024 Hungarian GP | McLaren F1 Team

Lando Norris confident McLaren will win after bagging 2024 Hungarian GP pole

Lando Norris is confident McLaren will win the 2024 Hungarian GP, owing to their impressive performance in race simulations...
George Russell in action at the 2024 Hungarian GP | Mercedes

Angry George Russell calls for Mercedes internal review after qualifying disaster

An angry George Russell called for a review within Mercedes after poor qualifying execution at the 2024 Hungarian Grand...
Oscar Piastri in the pit garage at the 2024 Austrian GP | McLaren F1 Team

Oscar Piastri hints at Lando Norris battle for 2024 Hungarian GP win

Oscar Piastri pointed to the long run down to Turn 1 at the Hungaroring as a potential way to...
Lewis Hamilton in action at the 2024 Hungarian GP | Mercedes

Lewis Hamilton targeting podium at 2024 Hungarian GP

Lewis Hamilton is aiming for a podium at the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix although he concedes McLaren and Red...

Max Verstappen slams Red Bull upgrade: Whole weekend not good enough

Max Verstappen ripped into Red Bull’s latest upgrade by declaring the whole weekend has been below his standards after...
Pascal Wehrlein of Porsche and Jaguar driver Mitch Evans during Round 15 at the London E-Prix | Formula E

Formula E title permutations and standings ahead of 2024 London E-Prix season finale

Things are hotting up in London as Nick Cassidy claimed pole position for the final race of the season...
- Advertisment -