Was McLaren right to use team orders at the Italian Grand Prix?

McLaren’s late team orders at Monza raised questions of fairness and set a potential precedent for the title fight

-

The 2025 Italian Grand Prix seemed to be heading towards a sedate conclusion when McLaren was the last of the frontrunning teams to call its drivers in for a pitstop.

But an issue for Lando Norris saw his position switch with Formula 1 championship rival and teammate Oscar Piastri, only for McLaren team orders to rectify the situation.

So was the Papaya squad right to intervene?

The situation arose because of McLaren‘s inability to challenge Max Verstappen‘s Red Bull on race day. Norris had got ahead at the start only to be overtaken by the end of lap four.

With Verstappen scampering down the road and able to extend his stint far past the window Pirelli had provided pre-race for the medium tyres, McLaren knew that a race win could then only come by waiting for a safety car and a free pitstop.

That neutralisation never came – though Carlos Sainz and Oliver Bearman tried with a collision at the Roggia chicane – and left the Woking-based outfit set for a certain two-three finish, if Piastri could emerge from the pits ahead of the rapidly-closing Ferrari of Charles Leclerc, who was one of the first of the frontrunners to pit.

More from the Singapore GP

Catch up with Total Motorsport's latest Singapore GP coverage, including Max Verstappen's victory at Marina Bay, Ferrari's costly strategy gamble, the full race classification, and the updated 2026 Formula 1 Drivers' and Constructors' Championship standings.

Norris had pitstop priority by being ahead on the road but passed that over to Piastri so that the podium could be secured, with the Australian being serviced in just 1.9 seconds.

A lap later and the Briton was in. But an issue on the left front left the wheel unfastened and the gun operator was forced to take another attempt at tightening the nut.

Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri celebrate with the team after the F1 2025 Italian Grand Prix | McLaren F1 Team
Lando Norris and Oscar Piastri celebrate with the team after the F1 2025 Italian Grand Prix | McLaren F1 Team

The extra four seconds stationary was enough for Norris to see Piastri undercut him and take second, which would have extended the gap in the championship to 37 points.

But it wasn’t long after the pitstop error for McLaren to give instructions to Piastri to hand the position back.

Team radio as it happened

Stallard: “Oscar this is a bit like Hungary last year, we pitted in this order for team reasons. Please let Lando past and you are free to race.”

Piastri: “I mean we said that a slow pitstop was a part of racing so I don’t really see what has changed here.”

After Piastri heeded instructions, Stallard then told Piastri: “You’re free to race. Clinical, clear head mate.”

Piastri‘s initial frustration was evident even though he did oblige and that is quite understandable. From his position, it was just how racing goes. But the fact that it was a McLaren mistake and not Norris‘, and the fact that the Briton had played the team game in order to stop second likely dictated the swap.

Lando Norris makes a pit stop during the F1 2025 Italian Grand Prix | McLaren F1 Team
Lando Norris makes a pit stop during the F1 2025 Italian Grand Prix | McLaren F1 Team

A clear distinction can be made between this scenario and the British Grand Prix where Piastri fell behind Norris by virtue of a time penalty.

There, Piastri was punished for a safety car infraction and asked if the places could have been swapped back, though Norris would eventually win the grand prix with no swap facilitated.

The culture at the team is most important and that has been evident all season. There has been no vitriol between team-mates despite the championship situation and it is clear both understand how important keeping the team together for the future will be instead of putting all focus and emotion into the current campaign.

And both drivers insisted that no precedent had now been set, with position changes only being made for team errors when the duo are next to each other on track.


More on the Italian GP


As Norris explained: “Every situation is different, so it’s pretty stupid just to assume that kind of thing and say that’s the precedent you set.

“We’re not idiots and we have plans for different things. If there were four cars in between me and Oscar, of course he’s not going to let me back past, and I don’t think it’s correct that he let me back past.

“But in a situation where we weren’t racing, in a situation where we can just be fair, then you’d expect to be fair, as a team. They don’t want to be the reason to upset one driver or another through no fault of their own. Today was not my fault.”

McLaren was right to swap the positions in the interest of fairness. But it was a controversy that it created all by itself.

Ewan Gale
Ewan Gale
Ewan Gale joined Total Motorsport ahead of the 2025 F1 season having served as a news editor for Autosport, as well as writing about Formula 1 for a number of other outlets on a full-time basis since 2020. After receiving his education at Silverstone, he transitioned into Formula 1 journalism following his university graduation. Throughout his career in the sport, he has covered numerous Grands Prix as an accredited media member and attended various pre-season car launches to report firsthand on major developments.

PODCAST

TRENDING

- Advertisment -