How did Mercedes go so wrong in Brazil – and why is there light at the end of the tunnel?

Mercedes retired George Russell from the 2023 Brazilian GP and Lewis Hamilton finished eighth, 63 seconds behind Max Verstappen


The departure of Mike Elliott ahead of the 2023 Brazilian Grand Prix looked set to complete Mercedes‘ fall and rise from their post-2021 blues, but instead culminated in their “worst weekend in 13 years” according to team principal Toto Wolff.

After sending their best technical brain gallivanting on boats for the biggest regulation change in a generation, Mercedes have been in the wilderness for two seasons, but returned to the scene of their last F1 victory with high hopes having finished runner-up in the last two races.

Though Elliott doesn’t bear sole responsibility for Mercedes‘ downfall, the scale of the team’s slump in his reign as technical director has, if anything, been slightly diminished as many view Red Bull‘s rise to dominance as inevitable in retrospect.

It wasn’t meant to be like this – Mercedes were thought to have switched to development for 2022 earlier than Red Bull – but as the team looked to move on from the Elliott era, there was at least one more nasty surprise in store at Interlagos.

Wolff: Fundamental mechanical problem for Mercedes

Dark skies in qualifying foreshadow an even darker 2023 Brazilian GP weekend for Mercedes | LAT Images/Mercedes F1 Team

Initially, things looked up for Mercedes in Brazil. George Russell was third in FP1 and even topped Q1, before Lewis Hamilton led a third-row lockout with plenty of reason to believe they could overhaul Aston Martin early on come race day.

But it turned out the dark skies in qualifying were just a taste of what was to come for the team, as their fortunes turned blacker than even the freakiest of storms come Sprint Saturday.

The team fell backwards in the sprint race with both drivers suffering paralytic tyre degradation, and Wolff was even asked post-grand prix whether Mercedes had considered switching to a pitlane start on Sunday in order to improve the setup.

“Yeah, we thought about that but we didn’t know fundamentally where we would’ve changed it because there’s a much bigger issue,” Wolff told the media. “When thinking about maximising points it was probably right to start like this.”

That’s arguably an even more damning indictment than the team’s solitary four-point haul from the grand prix – their joint-fifth-worst score since Hamilton joined the team in 2013 was the maximum they could’ve achieved.

Post-race, Hamilton and Russell both attributed some of their performance deficit to the high-drag setup gamble Mercedes took, but Wolff said the problem ran much deeper than that.

“We ran the car way too high, but that wasn’t the main reason for an absolute off weekend in terms of performance,” Wolff added. “There’s something fundamentally wrong mechanically, it’s not the rear wing and it’s not the car being slightly too high, that’s not the explanation for a total off-weekend.”

Where next for Mercedes?

Lewis Hamilton and George Russell hugging after the Sprint Race at the 2022 Brazilian Grand Prix
Lewis Hamilton and George Russell after F1 Sprint Race at the 2022 Brazilian GP | Mercedes F1 Team

There is light at the end of the tunnel though.

On paper, it looks like a massive fall from grace for Mercedes compared to 12 months ago, when Russell led a grand prix 1-2 in Sao Paolo and won the Sprint race.

However, Wolff found one very good reason to be cheerful. That Russell win in Interlagos cemented Mercedes‘ and Elliott‘s belief that their radical ‘zero sidepods’ concept could work.

They held that belief all through the winter and turned up to the season-opening 2023 Bahrain GP with an evolution of the W13, only to scrap the concept after qualifying and immediately consign another year to the waste bin.

But in stark contrast, last weekend at Interlagos has underlined why Mercedes must change for 2024, and Wolff is confident they can do just that.

“It’s a fundamentally different car next year and today proves that that is the right thing to do,” Wolff said. “It confirms that the trajectory of changing fundamentally is right.

“[Last year] we came out of an Interlagos weekend absolutely pumped, demolishing your competition Saturday and Sunday. And that was like, ‘are we doing the right thing by continuing with the chassis that we have’?

“And now it’s really clear, it’s been so horrible for the whole team and I wish we could start the new season and concentrate on the new car.”

It’s important to remember that two seasons shouldn’t define Elliott‘s career. He had a hand in all seven of Hamilton‘s championships and every Mercedes‘ success in the turbo-hybrid era, which still vastly outweighs their failures since 2022.

But while Interlagos wasn’t the full circle that Wolff hoped it’d be, it may have left one final gift from Elliott‘s doomed creation – the absolute certainty that only a total reset can get Mercedes back to fighting for championships.

Adam Dickinson
Adam Dickinson
An international multi-award-winning journalist, Adam Dickinson has written for since June 2022 and also contributes to TNT Sports, Eurosport and the Rugby Paper. He's also had articles published in the Daily Telegraph and several local newspapers, previously worked for and in motorsport, and graduated with a First-Class Journalism Degree from the University of Sheffield having also studied in Oklahoma. Adam started watching F1 by accident in 2007, catching the last race in Indianapolis, and attended his first race as a journalist at the 2023 British Grand Prix.
- Advertisment -


Lewis Hamilton, Lando Norris and Max Verstappen 1 at the 2024 British GP | Mercedes

F1 Driver Ratings — 2024 British GP

Lewis Hamilton finally ended his long wait for a race victory at the Formula 1 2024 British GP as...
George Russell leads the field into Turn 1 at the 2024 British GP | Mercedes

F1 Winners and Losers from the British GP

Lewis Hamilton emerged victorious in one of the most memorable races in recent Formula 1 history, which begs the...
Lewis Hamilton celebrates after winning the 2024 British GP | Mercedes

Lewis Hamilton masterclass proves he can take fight to Verstappen

Lewis Hamilton basked in the glory of his long-awaited victory at the British Grand Prix, celebrating in front of...
Max Verstappen looks on at the 2024 Austrian GP | Chris Graythen / Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Max Verstappen rues ‘poor’ British GP as Red Bull battle rare issue

Max Verstappen conceded it was a "poor afternoon" for Red Bull at the Formula 1 2024 British Grand Prix...
Lando Norris with engineers at 2024 British GP | McLaren F1 Team

Are McLaren becoming ‘new Ferrari’ after another strategy blunder?

Lando Norris' media appearances after the British GP were a genuinely tough watch, with reporters seemingly counselling the 24-year-old...
Race winner Lewis Hamilton of Mercedes Max Verstappen on the podium after the 2024 British Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Lewis Hamilton: British GP win more crucial to Mercedes than Russell victory

Lewis Hamilton explained why he felt his victory at the Formula 1 2024 British Grand Prix on Sunday was...
Carlos Sainz at the 2024 Austrian GP | Scuderia Ferrari Press Office

F1 2024 British GP – Fastest Lap

Carlos Sainz snatched the fastest lap at the 2024 British GP at the final opportunity as an all-time classic...
Lando Norris during 2024 British GP | McLaren F1 Team

F1 Standings after 2024 British Grand Prix

An emotional 2024 British Grand Prix saw Lewis Hamilton take a record-breaking win at Silverstone, outsmarting Lando Norris and...
Max Verstappen leads Lando Norris of McLaren during the 2024 British Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

F1 2024 British GP: Driver of the Day

There is a reason why the British Grand Prix remains the hottest attraction on the Formula 1 calendar and...
Lewis Hamilton celebrates after winning the 2024 British GP | Mercedes

Hamilton outsmarts Verstappen and Norris to clinch record-breaking British GP win

Lewis Hamilton finally celebrated on the top step of the podium after a dramatic finale to the Formula 1...
- Advertisment -