Haas protest of Australian GP result rejected

Haas protested the result of the 2023 Australian Grand Prix after Nico Hulkenberg was denied a first podium following an FIA decision to put the results back a lap


After Haas were summoned to the stewards for protesting the result of the 2023 Australian Grand Prix, the FIA dismissed the case from the US F1 team.

The controversial race was stopped twice to allow the marshals to clean up the track after pair of on-track incidents involving Alex Albon and Kevin Magnussen.

With five laps left, the race was restarted for a second time culminating in a multi-car pileup which eliminated both Alpines and Carlos Sainz’s pick up a five-second penalty for contact with Fernando Alonso.

Amidst all the chaos, Haas driver Nico Hulkenberg had spring-boarded himself up to fourth and with Sainz’s penalty, the German, who had never been on the podium F1, was suddenly in third.

But with the results being put back a lap, Hulkenberg was demoted back to seventh, enraging Haas, who protested the result a few after the race’s conclusion.

Lewis Hamilton ahead of Max Verstappen at the Australian Grand Prix | Mercedes F1 team

FIA decision

Haas had questioned the legitimacy of the order of the grid upon the race restart after Red Flag event on Lap 57/58 rather than the classification itself. 

Art. 57.3 of the F1 Sporting Regulation states: “In all cases the order will be taken at the last point at which it was possible to determine the position of all cars…” 

The race was resumed after another Red Flag incident. Very shortly thereafter, there was a further Red Flag incident within the first two corners of the resumed race and Race Control had to determine what the order of the grid ought to be for the next restart based on Art. 57.3.

Race Control determined that the last point at which it was possible to the determine the position of all cars was when the last grid was formed. 

Given that Race Control and the Race Director needed to be make a prompt decision, the stewards decided that the circumstances in determining the grid order were appropriate and dismissed the protest.  

Circuit organisers in trouble for track invasion

Haas was joined in the stewards’ office by the Australian Grand Prix Organisation after a track invasion just as Max Verstappen led the field over the start and finish straight. 

Following the invasion, a red flag was thrown despite the race ending with over 131,000 fans invading the circuit to join in with the post-race celebrations.

It marks the second season where an F1 race had been invaded before the race’s conclusion as six Just Stop Oil members stopped the 2022 British GP after sitting down on the Wellington straight.

Ed Spencer
FIA accredited journalist
- Advertisment -


Emotional Cassidy ‘incredibly sad’ to miss out in dramatic Formula E title race

Nick Cassidy was almost lost for words after he dramatically lost the 2024 Formula E title to Pascal Wehrlein...

Why NASCAR waited and ended the Brickyard 400 under caution

Kyle Larson, a Hendrick Motorsports driver, winning the Brickyard 400 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway on the thirty-year anniversary of...

Max Verstappen slams Red Bull over shocking 2024 Hungarian GP performance

Max Verstappen slams Red Bull for a shocking display at the 2024 Hungarian GP, calling the car slow and...

Emotional Oscar Piastri relives maiden F1 win at Hungarian GP

An emotional Oscar Piastri said his 2024 Hungarian GP victory was a “dream come true” as he took his...

Colton Herta Triumphs in Toronto, Ending 40-Race Winless Streak

Michael Andretti’s jubilant reaction following the IndyCar Grand Prix of Toronto at Exhibition Place was unmistakable as Colton Herta...

Victory and redemption: Pascal Wehrlein’s road to becoming Formula E champion

Following a wide-open battle that boiled down to the very last race of the 2024 season, Pascal Wehrlein officially...

Evans hits out at Jaguar: Team were working against me in Formula E finale

Mitch Evans feels his Jaguar team were working against him during the Formula E finale in London as he...

London E-Prix Results 2024 – Formula E Round 16

Pascal Wehrlein emerged victorious in one of the most dramatic races in Formula E history, securing his maiden Drivers'...

Max Verstappen escapes crash penalty: Blames Lewis Hamilton

Max Verstappen blames Lewis Hamilton for turning in too early for their Hungaroring crash on July 21 as the...

F1 Standings after 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix

Oscar Piastri secured his first Formula 1 victory at the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix amid internal McLaren drama with...
- Advertisment -
Exit mobile version