F1 vs Formula E vs WRC: Who has the best drivers?

Is Formula E more competitive than F1? Does the WRC have the best racing drivers in motorsport?

-

Formula 1 is widely seen as the pinnacle of motorsport, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they have the very best racing drivers in the world.

The rise of Formula E and the incredible skills of the top rally drivers in the World Rally Championship mean the debate about which motorsport series has the best drivers is not simple.

Of course, comparing different championships is difficult because F1, Formula E and WRC require completely different skill sets.

But, the principles of driving a car as quick as possible is the same, so which series has the best drivers?

Formula E Jaguar Gen2 car and Red Bull 2022 F1 car

F1 vs Formula E

In the first few seasons of Formula E, the all-electric championship undoubtedly had a weaker grid compared to F1.

The quality of the Formula E field has risen significantly since the start of the Gen2 era in 2018.

In an exclusive intetview with Total-Motorsport.com, Oliver Rowland suggested the average driver level in Formula E is higher than F1.

“I didn’t think you could put any F1 driver in Formula E where they would win easily,” explained Rowland.

“I think Max [Verstappen] is the standout in F1 at the moment in terms of pace, talent and just natural ability.

“I rate the others highly, especially the younger guys like Charles [Leclerc] and George [Russell].

“But they wouldn’t come here and dominate. I know that, I’ve raced against them and I know their level.

“I would say the average here [in Formula E] is better [than F1]. I would welcome them here any time.”

To perform well in Formula E, you need to have top notch racecraft and a smart head. The cars often run nose to tail, so having the skills to defend and attack on the limit of what is allowed is key to success in Formula E.

Compared to F1, where DRS boosts a driver’s chance of overtaking, Formula E has the strategy of attack mode, which has the same amount of usage for everyone, so is more fair in that sense.

Most tracks in Formula E are street circuits, so the margin of error is tiny and there is no need for talk about track limits.

Mistakes are punished and if you’re not happy with the balance of the car, you will easily find yourself out of contention for a top five, and maybe even the points altogether.

Looking back at junior series, there are several examples of Formula E drivers beating current F1 drivers.

Stoffel Vandoorne, DS Penske, DS E-Tense FE23 Norman Nato, Nissan Formula E Team, Nissan e-4ORCE 04 Pascal Wehrlein, TAG Heuer Porsche Formula E Team, Porsche 99X Electric Gen3 Start

For instance, the 2015 Formula 3 European Championship saw Felix Rosenqvist comfortably win the title from Antonio Giovinazzi.

Jake Dennis was third, Charles Leclerc fourth with Lance Stroll, George Russell, Alex Albon and Maximilian Gunther completing the top eight.

In general though, the best drivers do make it to F1 but there are definitely some cases where some haven’t been given the same chance to reach what is seen as the top of motorsport.

Does WRC have the best drivers?

Then there is the rally driver factor. The ability for a human being to drive a car as fast as they can on tight roads, in all conditions, on different surfaces whilst listening to pace notes from their co-driver.

Prior to the sensational Kalle Rovanpera, the youngest WRC world champion was Colin McRae at 25 years old, underlining the need for experience and how difficult it is to be quick and consistent straight away.

Kalle Rovanpera 2022 FIA World Rally Championship / Round 11 / Rally New Zealand 2022 / 29th September – 2nd October 2022// Worldwide Copyright: Toyota Gazoo Racing WRT

Rally events span three or four days and whilst they are not as long as they used to be in terms of distance, trying to nail every stage and make the right decisions is more difficult than circuit racing.

Think about this. Put a single-seating racing driver, be it from F1 or Formula E, in a rally car and they would be over a minute off the pace over a standard rally stage.

Put a rally driver in a single-seater car and they will almost certainly find it easier. In that sense, rallying is more pure and requires more skill. You will find it difficult to make an argument that other racing drivers have the same completeness when it comes to driving.

Nigel Chiu
Nigel Chiuhttps://total-motorsport.com/author/nigel-chiu/
Nigel Chiu is an NCTJ-qualified journalist who worked at Total-Motorsport for 18 months until May 2023. He has been following F1 since 2007 and hasn’t missed a Grand Prix weekend since. Nigel’s worked with several motorsport websites, plus Eurosport and subsequently went on to work with Sky Sports F1 where he travels to multiple F1 races each season.
- Advertisment -

LATEST NEWS

Max Verstappen in the F1 paddock ahead of the 2024 Spanish Grand Prix | Chris Graythen / Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Mercedes chairman flirts with Max Verstappen: He’d look good in silver

0
One of the most important figures within Mercedes AMG, Ola Kallenius, has declared Max Verstappen “would look good in...
Carlos Sainz during practice for the 2024 Spanish GP | Scuderia Ferrari Press Office

Carlos Sainz hits out at Lewis Hamilton over unpunished Spanish GP move

0
Carlos Sainz believes Lewis Hamilton should've been given a penalty for his overtaking move that forced the Ferrari driver...
Max Verstappen during 2024 Spanish GP Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Max Verstappen warning to Red Bull and demands improvement

0
Max Verstappen demands Red Bull improvement as another tough race saw the reigning world champion have to really work...
Start of the 2024 Spanish Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

LIVE F1 Spanish Grand Prix 2024 – Reaction as McLaren mistakes costly as Verstappen...

0
Welcome to Total-Motorsport’s F1 live coverage of the Spanish GP 2024. Held at the iconic Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya, today’s race...
Lewis Hamilton during 2024 Spanish GP weekend | Mercedes

Lewis Hamilton brushes off furious Sainz after Spanish GP incident

0
Lewis Hamilton risked angering Carlos Sainz after claiming the Ferrari driver "left the door open" to overtake him during...
Lando Norris of McLaren after the 2024 Spanish Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Lando Norris: McLaren easily had the best car at Spanish GP

0
Lando Norris believes Spanish GP victory should have been his as McLaren had the best car in Barcelona, but...
Red Bull Team Principal Christian Horner at the 2024 Monaco Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Christian Horner warns of Norris danger to Verstappen after Spanish GP battle

0
Red Bull team principal Christian Horner warned that Lando Norris and McLaren are their strongest competitors following a nail-biting...
McLaren team principal Andrea Stella at the 2023 Belgian GP | McLaren F1 team

McLaren chief pinpoints where 2024 Spanish GP was lost

0
McLaren's team boss they lost the 2024 Spanish GP by Turn 1 as a poor start saw Lando Norris...
Max Verstappen, Lando Norris and Lewis Hamilton on the podium after the 2024 Spanish GP | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

F1 Standings after 2024 Spanish Grand Prix

0
Max Verstappen showcased his racing prowess at the 2024 Spanish Grand Prix, clinching his seventh victory of the Formula...
Lando Norris during the 2024 Spanish GP weekend | McLaren

F1 Fastest Lap: Spanish GP 2024

0
The Spanish GP Fastest Lap award is given to the driver who posts the quickest time over one timed...
- Advertisment -