Should F1 drivers be penalised for causing a red flag?

Should drivers be punished for causing a red flag in Formula 1 qualifying sessions?


Qualifying – the most intense moment of a Formula 1 race weekend, where one bad mistake, such as running into traffic or being sent out at the wrong time, can ruin a Grand Prix before the red lights go out.

But some things are out of the driver’s control, one of those things being the presence of a red flag during a session, caused by anything from fan disobedience to debris or even a damaged barrier.

However, the most common cause of a red flag is a driver hitting the barrier after simply trying too hard on a push lap, slamming the wall and turning a six-figure car into scrap in seconds.

These lapses of judgement delay the session as the marshals need time to clear the track, ruining other drivers’ laps and causing some to question whether drivers should be penalised for causing a red flag.

So does F1 need to take a leaf out of IndyCar’s books and implement a rule which punishes drivers for their mistakes?

The crashed car of IndyCar Series driver Colton Herta is unloaded by a tow truck as crew members pull out the back car in the garage area after crashing. Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

The case for such a rule

In 2022, five qualifying sessions saw red flags brought out to stop proceedings, with some sessions having multiple stoppages delaying the calumniation of qualifying.

Session-stopping accidents have caused series like IndyCar and Formula E to adopt a policy where if a driver causes a red flag, they lose their fastest time as well as have to spend a considerable amount of time in the pit lane if they manage to free themselves from the barrier.

Carlos Sainz, a victim of a red flag in Monte Carlo that cost him a chance of snatching pole position from teammate Charles Leclerc, now says that he and his fellow competitors want a similar rule introduced to end the culture of drivers getting away with their mistakes.

“I think it’s for real now that all drivers want some kind of a rule that, if you generate a red flag or a yellow flag, even if it’s intentional or not, there should be something done to that driver, because you’ve compromised the other nine on purpose, or maybe not,” said Sainz.

“But you should get a penalty for it. If not, we’re all going to start playing with it. And I’ve seen over the last few years a lot more play around with it than what you might even have picked out in the media.”

Zak Brown is also in agreement with the Spaniard and his fellow drivers believing the system would be easy to implement and could have a variety of penalties.

“I think what Carlos said, I think it should be red flags or yellow flags, for effectively impeding a driver from completing their lap,” said Brown to

“They do that in other forms of motorsports, the penalties, you just lose your fastest lap from that session, and all the drivers tend to do one lap runs so that would penalise the driver if it was intentional or unintentional. Because you’ve messed up someone else’s lap.

“I think that’s an easy solution; it can be implemented right away. You cause a driver to have to back out; you lose your lap, you get to go again and maybe you won’t have a chance.”

Would it work?

Not everyone is a fan of the idea, with Aston Martin team principal Mike Krack claiming that the concept would be hard to regulate.

“I do not have a black-and-white opinion on this,” said Krack. “I think we need to really look case-by-case, going to sporting advisory and maybe have a look at the last 10 years where we had situations because it’s quite quick to pre-condemn someone when it was not good.

“I think it would be easy to say, yeah, it has to be like that, but I think it will be a tough call to do it.”

Formula One F1 – Azerbaijan Grand Prix – Baku City Circuit, Baku, Azerbaijan – June 11, 2022 Aston Martin’s Sebastian Vettel hits a barrier during qualifying REUTERS/Murad Sezer

Krack does raise an excellent point, how would the system be regulated and what would be the proper penalty for causing a red flag?

But ultimately, if the drivers agree on the new rule, then the governing body should implement it; after all, if they make their mistakes, why shouldn’t they face the consequences?

In this writer’s opinion, the best way of policing such a system would be to have a two-tier penalty system with drivers causing a deliberate accident or simply pushing too hard, losing their fastest lap, whilst a non-deliberate shunt would carry a penalty of a drive-through that must be served during the race.

New regulations take time to implement, but this should be fast-tracked as it would stop drivers from pushing beyond the limit to shave a thousandth of a second off their lap time.

Yes, qualifying should remain the ultimate test for drivers, but they should be made to think twice about their competitors when taking a dangerous approach to a corner, as their mistake impacts not just themselves and their mechanics but also their competitors.

Ed Spencer
Ed Spencer
FIA accredited journalist
- Advertisment -


Adrian Newey, the Chief Technical Officer of Red Bull during 2024 Saudi Arabian Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Aston Martin executive gives cryptic update on Adrian Newey deal

Aston Martin’s technical director Dan Fallows has admitted Adrian Newey would be “a great asset” to any team but...
Oscar Piastri with the winners trophy at the 2024 Hungarian GP | McLaren F1 Team

Piastri wants McLaren discussion after Hungarian GP team orders chaos

Oscar Piastri called for a McLaren discussion regarding the team orders situation at the 2024 Hungarian GP as he...
The start of the 2024 Hungarian GP | Mark Thompson / Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

F1 Driver Ratings – 2024 Hungarian GP

Oscar Piastri stunned fans at the Hungaroring by taking his first career victory at the 2024 F1 Hungarian Grand...
Nick Cassidy walking down the pit lane at the 2024 London E-Prix | Formula E

Emotional Cassidy ‘incredibly sad’ to miss out in dramatic Formula E title race

Nick Cassidy was almost lost for words after he dramatically lost the 2024 Formula E title to Pascal Wehrlein...
Kyle Larson of the #5 Chevrolet, celebrates in victory lane after winning 2024 NASCAR Cup Series Brickyard 400 | NASCAR / Getty Images

Why NASCAR waited and ended the Brickyard 400 under caution

Kyle Larson, a Hendrick Motorsports driver, winning the Brickyard 400 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway on the thirty-year anniversary of...
Max Verstappen leads Lewis Hamilton of Mercedes during the 2024 Hungarian Grand Prix | Getty Images / Red Bull Content Pool

Max Verstappen slams Red Bull over shocking 2024 Hungarian GP performance

Max Verstappen slams Red Bull for a shocking display at the 2024 Hungarian GP, calling the car slow and...
Oscar Piastri celebrates winning the 2024 Hungarian GP | McLaren F1 Team

Emotional Oscar Piastri relives maiden F1 win at Hungarian GP

An emotional Oscar Piastri said his 2024 Hungarian GP victory was a “dream come true” as he took his...
Colton Herta wins the IndyCar 2024 Grand Prix of Toronto | Penske Entertainment: Travis Hinkle

Colton Herta Triumphs in Toronto, Ending 40-Race Winless Streak

Michael Andretti’s jubilant reaction following the IndyCar Grand Prix of Toronto at Exhibition Place was unmistakable as Colton Herta...
Pascal Wehrlein celebrates winning the Formula E championship at the London E-Prix | Formula E

Victory and redemption: Pascal Wehrlein’s road to becoming Formula E champion

Following a wide-open battle that boiled down to the very last race of the 2024 season, Pascal Wehrlein officially...
Mitch Evans looks on at the 2024 Portland E-Prix | Formula E

Evans hits out at Jaguar: Team were working against me in Formula E finale

Mitch Evans feels his Jaguar team were working against him during the Formula E finale in London as he...
- Advertisment -